2008 National Men's
Collegiate Division 3
Rugby Championship
Prepared by Dillon
Prime, Event Co-Director
with additional
commentary by
Steve Cohen,
NSCRO Director
Venue: Hamilton
College,
Clinton, New York
Dates: April 26-27,
2008
Forward: The National
Men's Collegiate Division 3
Rugby playoffs and
championships are run under
the governance of the
National Small College Rugby
Organization (NSCRO). NSCRO
founders and directors are
Steve Cohen (
president@epru.org)
and Chip Auscavitch (
chip@nerfu.org).
It is run independently from
the USA Rugby National
playoff system (since USA
Rugby does not have a
Collegiate Division 3
playoff system) but with the
knowledge and acceptance of
USA Rugby.
Attached to this email you
will find the format and
results of the entire D3
playoffs including
identification of all
competing clubs in each LAU
that were eligible to win
the Championship.
Summary:
Congratulations first goes
to all collegiate Division 3
clubs that began this
journey, some last August
with "summer" practice
sessions. Secondly,
congratulation to Plymouth
State for winning this
National Championship as
well as the other finalists.
This is no doubt that D3
collegiate rugby, primarily
based in "small colleges"
has proven itself worthy of
recognition by the USA Rugby
community as being a worthy
endeavor by
student-athletes. While a
sizable portion of the
country does not have the
depth / numbers of college
clubs playing rugby as found
in the "eastern" United
States that allows them to
establish more than 2
collegiate divisions, this
does not mean that "small
college" should be left out
of event such as this that
recognizes their efforts on
and off the field of play.
The event began in 2002 as
the "East Coast" D3
Championship and in 2007
became a "National"
championship. Similar "small
college", D3 and D4 National
Championships are held for
the Women.
While many folks look for a
way to best and fairly
define collegiate rugby
clubs as D1, D2 and D3. The
NSCRO at this time simply
looks to the LAUs governing
these clubs to identify the
division that best suits the
needs of their clubs.
Clubs or Unions that are not
currently participating in a
D3 collegiate league that is
included in the NSCRO
structure and would like
more information about it
should contact
Steve Cohen.
Preparation: The prep
work that went in was
extensive and cooperative.
Dave Thompson and all of the
offices at Hamilton did a
fantastic job bringing this
tournament to life. The
field was beautiful. Medical
staff was professional and
accessible. Bathrooms were
provided. Parking was easy.
Everyone got directions to
the field in advance. A
scoreboard was made
available. An accapella
group was found to do the
national anthem. The weekend
event programs were
excellent. Todd Miller from
Longwood University received
a moment of silence. Every
detail was well scripted and
it is little surprise that
the weekend ran as smooth as
silk.
Game Play: What a
fantastic display of Rugby
put on by all. These teams
played at an incredible
level for Division 3 Rugby.
Game 1 SemiFinal:
Plymouth State (New England
RFU) 38 vs. Hamilton (NY
State RC) 8
Game one showed just how
high a level of Rugby is
coming out of New England.
Plymouth was large, fit,
disciplined, and very
skilled in the art of rugby.
Hamilton played a solid game
but showed some positional
weaknesses as well as a
general lack of continuity.
While Hamilton was missing 6
starters from the fall due
to its abroad programs, the
high caliber of the PSU
skills was undeniable. They
overloaded Hamilton
offensively and defensively
and beat them squarely on
their home field.
Game 2 SemiFinal: Furman
(Palmetto RU) 31 vs. Widener
(East Penn RU) 20
Game two was fast paced,
hard hitting, and long
lasting. While the speed and
creativity of the Paladin
backline was quick and
frustrated Widener. But the
East Penn boys in their
yellow socks refused to go
away. The Widener fullback
hit a drop goal during
running play. The Widener
forwards broke tackles and
disrupted Furman's offense.
The Widener spirit showed
its tenacity despite the
sizable deficit right up to
the final whistle. In the
end Furman was just too
much. They were, in my
opinion, the most fit and
offensively dangerous team
at the tournament.
Game
3 3rd Place: Widener
33 vs. Hamilton 17
The final score at the
end of this game was a
question of drive. Hamilton
came out fairly flat and
Widener came out blazing.
Hamilton fell behind early
and Widener never let up.
Now Hamilton did do an
excellent job of keeping its
cool under pressure.
Oppositely, several Widener
players found themselves in
the sin bin over the course
of the game. Mike Walsh,
Widener 8-man, played a
complete game showing both
skill and leadership. He was
awarded him a game ball for
his efforts.
Game 4 Final: Plymouth
State (PSU) 22 vs. Furman 17
Sensational game play
for 80 minutes. Furman
jumped up early using its
creative backline and
powerfully aggressive
forwards. PSU spent a good
deal of time on its own goal
line. Still, in the second
half, PSU would not be
denied. With less than 20
minutes to go, PSU closed
the gap and tied the game
with 3 minutes to play. I
did not see the
controversial pass that lead
to the PSU go-ahead-score,
but I will say it happened
after the clock had expired.
In those moments I cannot
possibly blame a referee for
going with his gut reaction
to the situation rather than
second guessing. The game
was hard fought. Furman's
8-man got the game ball and
Rob Howe (PSUs fly half and
captain) got the MVP.
Team trophies were awarded
to the top 3 finishers.
The NSCRO wants to extend
its thanks to Brad Jones
(Head Coach, Hamilton
College RFC) for leading the
effort in hosting this event
along with his club, Dave
Thompson and all other
Hamilton College, Event
Co-Directors, Dillon Prime
and Allen Horak (Hamilton
College alums), match
officials and the NY State
Rugby Conference along with
everyone else responsible
for making this an
"excellent" rugby experience
for all involved.
The NSCRO appreciates the
financial support of the
LAUs that the participating
clubs that allows clubs to
compete without entrance
fees.